Chris Levey, Thayer School of Engineering, Dartmouth College
January 29, 1995
CROSS SECTION: The cross section doesn't work properly. Most layers are exactly reverse of what they should be (e.g. poly looks like a poly cut)! The cross section is an extremely valuable teaching tool. This is THE MAJOR BUG FOR US. PLEASE FIX THIS ASAP.
COPY CELL: when a new name is entered for the cell to be copied, the new cell still has the old name (at least when copying from one file to another).
COPY CELL: When duplicate cell exists, asked to Rename. Responding OK always causes a CRASH of L-Edit (error type 1).
TECHNOLOGY UNITS: Changing the unit sizes in the Technology Parameters dialog box causes the Macintosh to BOMB. E.g. start with 1IU=1 micron, then change to 1IU=1/10 lambda. Mouse freezes as one exits the dialog box.
HIGH PERFORMANCE GRAPHICS cause a BOMB of a powerbook 165c
COMMAND CLICK PALLET should report e.g. "show poly" below the pallet. It says nothing.
CONTROL CLICK doesn't add vertices to a polygon as documented.
ADD/EDIT: use of control key to get "add/edit" button"--the label doesn't change to indicate use.
REDRAW: When switching between programs on Mac, the window shade function (system 7.5) will leave an empty L-Edit window.
L-EDIT MAC/PC TDB FILE INCOMPATABLE: We get a format error when trying to read a TDB file written by the MAC on the PC student version. THis is a particular problem because the student version won't read any other format than TDB. PAN: The "hand" here operates exactly opposite to the way it does in all other macintosh programs. The convention is for the hand to drag the objects, not to move the window. If you want to move the window, use another icon.
SNAP TO GRID: Why not implement on the mac?
POSTSCRIPT PRINTING: Why not implement on the mac? We need to get the highest possible quality output for making low resolution masks from a printer. In this regard, it would be great to have a "print true scale" option, or "print n* scale" (for photographic reduction).
ABORT: IS there a way to abort a generate layers command? There should be an abort button for any command that takes more than half a minute!
CROSS SECTION FILES: Opening .XST file--only works if in same directory as device (though the dialog box recognizes files in other directories and indicates that they should open (not grey), it won't open them).
SUGGESTION: When a dialog box allows the user to select a layer from the pallet, put a button around the word "layer". Clicking the button could then inform the user that the pallet is live.
SUGGESTION: I really got stuck trying to figure out how to copy from one file to another. It's not intuitive for a mac user. WHy not do the following: When the copy buffer has a cell from another file, the paste command should bring up a warning dialog box (with optional cancel) allowing the user to verify that all instanced cells will also be copied, then do the copy. If that's too hard for this version, it should at least bring up an explanation of how to do a copy from one file to another.
SUGGESTION--ROTATE: An arbitrary angle rotate (such as in ClarisCAD) would be nice.
SUGGESTION--DONGLE: It would be more convenient if the dongle check happened only at application startup, not also at system startup. If I bring the dongle to another person's machine, we must restart the machine before using L-Edit. That's a real pain.
SUGGESTION--CROSS SECTION: It would be nice if there was a way to print a cross section (not just a screen dump), or better, to copy it to the clipboard. The first thing we wanted to do with L-Edit was generate cross section graphics for some undergraduate lab writeups. We ended up doing them from scratch in ClarisCAD instead...
NON MANHATTAN GEOMETRY: The lack of processing in L-Edit for any non manhattan geometry is a major disappointment for us. Circles and polygons with odd angles can be drawn, but they can not be used to generate layers or cross sections. I have written a Macintosh application to generate staircase (Manhattan geometry) circles, annuli, spokes, and teeth for L-Edit, but use of these many sided polygons slows down L-Edit.